This is the ONLY correct version on YT. The rest all get the intro double stop slide wrong then they play the rest of the track in first position. Of course it’s completely ok to play the track with your own variations and note choices, but this is an accurate score of this brilliant groove by Rainey
This bass line almost seems predestined it's so perfect for the song. I think the biggest challenge as a bassist is to write something that's interesting that actually enhances the song rather than distracts. A lot of bassists will just settle for root notes so they're not obtrusive. But this bass line is a perfect example of how you can take advantage of space, countermelody, and syncopation to push against what's there in a positive way.
Listening to Steely Dan is like laying down in a hot summer night and watching the stars....making you feel really small and insignificant. These musicians are out of this world and it does not matter who is in the band at the time....bass ,keys, guitar whoever, will play along the line and not note for notes adding their own feel. But the real question is :"How do they do it?"
I saw on a retrospective that Walter Becker hummed this bass line to Chuck Rainey to get across what he wanted, and of course Julia aces it. This is a savvy group of Dan fans and you're keeping us happy!
My Gosh!!! Like @szmkabels said: proper lesson, I am so grateful. Real notation, kind considerate pacing with metronome and coaching for nuances. This is the kind of course instruction I look for. Theory and pragmatic approach with a song to hook my fleeting attention to. Thank you Julia!
@@ThomannsGuitarsBasses Cheers Back :-) I'm off to a Minneapolis Gig in the freezing morning. 2 Hours supporting former addicts, abused women and ex-convicts. You can imagine, they are grateful. We will all have the best time ever! I would have never believed my old Peavey Foundation would bless folks this way. Thanks! That's Bass at 70!!!
A lot of people can just play the notes and even play them on time. But you add just the right 'feel' to it. Great job, excellent instruction and playing! Thanks for sharing!
Love it Julia great breakdown of a legendary song and legendary bass player.On a side note my father victor feldman is playing fender rhodes piano on this.
Your father is a legend, and brought joy to so many, in so many classics from Steely Dan, Zappa, and countless jazz recordings! I'm used to hearing him on mallet percussion - didn't know he was on Rhodes on this tune! Amazing!
I like the way you put that in segments. Those Steely Dan bass lines are awesome, and you play them expertly, with all the feeling, thus the "bass face"!
As always Julia CRUSHES her tutorials! Great post and this was super clear. I think that Josie was a really funky fun bass with lots of style (as in 70s bell bottoms and sequins, but I digress). Loved this, and I'm a fan of the Steely Dan popular songs like this. They recorded so clearly and with such excellent tone that its hard not to love their music if you like cool jazzy fusion like sounds. I will use this tutorial to learn how to play it better than I imagined I could previously.
I was hooked the first time I saw you here and the more I watch the more I like your content. I’ve seen a few videos today and they inspires me to dust off my old bass and try to learn some groovy bass lines. I’m just a happy amateur who used to play in a local rock band with some strong country influences. Nothing fancy really. But I really like the groove from the 70th. You have a sweet style Julia. There is something about the way you express your passion for music.
Hi Julia, I love watching how you enjoy playing the bass. It is contagious. I'm a big Steely Dan/Donald Fagen fan and a beginner bass player. Muchas gracias desde El Paso, TX!
Thank you so much Julia never did I think this bass line was attainable for me as a bassist.Your breakdown and comprehension made it so I was able to unlock it and have sooooo much fun
Wow, I don't even play bass and watched this entire video. Have been listening to this track since the album was released in '77 and didn't know how sophisticated Mr. Rainey's part was. Sublime!
I often find myself having to learn 30 to 40 new songs for a band I just joined with pending gigs. In this situation, I cut to the chase and look for isolated bass tracks or bass lessons. This video is far and away the best bass lesson I have found on RUclips! The flow and the pace are perfect for me! Thank you Julia Hofer! You will be the first place I check from now on!
I'm not a bassist, but I am a big fan of the instrument. You covered this perfectly, including little details so many others might have missed, such as NOT going back to the E on the first time through the figure in the intro, but doing so every other time. Also, your intonation is so clean. Great work!
That Bass line was jointly constructed by Chuck Rainey and Walter Becker. Becker was thinking Cop movie incidental music and Chuck embellished it. Great job breaking it down here. The making of AJA is a great Documentary.
Julia, thanks a lot for the lesson. It's inspiring how the groove comes out of you. Please make a lesson for the song San Francisco by Brother Strut. Please
I have seen your work in years and how you cover some of the famous bass lines esp this SD bass....I just had to watch all over again and marvel at how Chuck Rainey was a Bass badass...again thanks for doing this...😅😮😅😮😊
Thank you so much sweetie, I have loved this song since It came out (yes I’m old) . Your RUclips movie lesson makes me feel like taking out my bass and learn it. I have enjoyed all of your “Top” bass lines movies but never knew you do how to play it lessons. To groove young lady. I subscribed and did that bell thing long ago but now I’m going to learn how to search. LoL. I wonder if the 30 year old strings on my “P” will still sound good. Hope the tubes in my amp all light up. God Bless sweetheart and keep healthy and yes your playing is inspirational. Most Sincerely, Pops Fitch
I just discovered your channel last night and dayum... After watching this tutorial, it might become one of my favorites! Learning to play the bass guitar has been on my bucket list for decades; and watching this video is inspiring!!
Thanks for posting Julia, I learned this a few years ago and your tutorial is so clear and concise. Greatly appreciated. Chuck Rainey what can you say - he's so groovy.
One of the coolest basslines played by one of the coolest bassplayers. Kudos to you Julia. I have loved playing this bassline and your expressions show you really are channelling Chuck Rainey. I note that it is evident that a bass player wrote this, unlike many songs that it is just a simple backing. He expertly provides a solid foundation but adds the tasty licks, runs and syncopation that makes this outstanding. André in Sydney
The thing with Steely Dan is that you can do that with literally every instrument and the vocals. All parts are incredibly groovy, complex, and recorded to perfection.
Steely Dan is always a good time on the bass guitar. Pretty cool Julia. Another band that is always fun on the bass, is early Chicago. I love comping Peter Cetera's bass lines. He's always been very underrated.
Amazing, I have been trying to learn this song for so long (Correctly) and even though I had the tab and even a lesson (JUST TO LEARN THIS SONG) all i got was some tab and as much as I can cram within an hour lesson and watching the clock.. I never got the feel of it. Thank you Julia!
You are wonderful! I'd have to fly from California each week for lessons, but it would be worth it. Love the explanations, slowing it down, and the tablature. Thanks much.
Thank you very much Julia for this class. I can finally play a song I like a lot like the original, I'm happy. Could you in future videos show us more songs? Bye
Julia does such an amazing job of reproducing these parts! I would be highly interested in hearing about her method of figuring these things out.....Please share!
Fantastic, you are wonderfull, thanks very much, this realy helped me a lot , quite a difficult song, got to be done right,, you realy helped me ,, exelent😊
![Steely Dan - Josie [BASS COVER] - with notation and tabs](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Mz_1kaBrFgk/mqdefault.jpg)
I've seen a lot of different bass 'lessons' or covers on this song, but I believe this is the only *CORRECT* version I've seen to date.
This is the ONLY correct version on YT. The rest all get the intro double stop slide wrong then they play the rest of the track in first position. Of course it’s completely ok to play the track with your own variations and note choices, but this is an accurate score of this brilliant groove by Rainey
I believe the double stop should be D & G not E & G
@@pedullabassTalking about the intro right? No that's definitely E and G, though the E is a bit faint in the album recording!
This bass line almost seems predestined it's so perfect for the song. I think the biggest challenge as a bassist is to write something that's interesting that actually enhances the song rather than distracts. A lot of bassists will just settle for root notes so they're not obtrusive. But this bass line is a perfect example of how you can take advantage of space, countermelody, and syncopation to push against what's there in a positive way.
Listening to Steely Dan is like laying down in a hot summer night and watching the stars....making you feel really small and insignificant. These musicians are out of this world and it does not matter who is in the band at the time....bass ,keys, guitar whoever, will play along the line and not note for notes adding their own feel.
But the real question is :"How do they do it?"
Thanks, Julia! A day which starts with a Steely Dan lesson by Julia is as good day indeed!
I saw on a retrospective that Walter Becker hummed this bass line to Chuck Rainey to get across what he wanted, and of course Julia aces it. This is a savvy group of Dan fans and you're keeping us happy!
My Gosh!!! Like @szmkabels said: proper lesson, I am so grateful. Real notation, kind considerate pacing with metronome and coaching for nuances. This is the kind of course instruction I look for. Theory and pragmatic approach with a song to hook my fleeting attention to. Thank you Julia!
Thank you! // Cheers, Julia
💯
@@ThomannsGuitarsBasses Cheers Back :-) I'm off to a Minneapolis Gig in the freezing morning. 2 Hours supporting former addicts, abused women and ex-convicts. You can imagine, they are grateful. We will all have the best time ever! I would have never believed my old Peavey Foundation would bless folks this way. Thanks! That's Bass at 70!!!
A lot of people can just play the notes and even play them on time. But you add just the right 'feel' to it. Great job, excellent instruction and playing! Thanks for sharing!
Thank you so much! // Cheers, Julia
Ordentliche Lektür ❤❤❤proper lesson
Love the bass line! Steely Dan was the music of my teen years! Always enjoy your videos, Julia 😊
Love it Julia great breakdown of a legendary song and legendary bass player.On a side note my father victor feldman is playing fender rhodes piano on this.
Your father is a legend, and brought joy to so many, in so many classics from Steely Dan, Zappa, and countless jazz recordings! I'm used to hearing him on mallet percussion - didn't know he was on Rhodes on this tune! Amazing!
@@spoontastico Thank you very much for the very kind words in regards to my father.
@@spoontastico lmao, and how do you know it's not a hoax? If I say that my _uncle_ Jim Keltner is on drums, would you also believe it?
@@UttaraMimamsa what's the downside of assuming it's true?
Victor Feldman is a very underappreciated keyboardist whether he’s your father or not.😊
I like the way you put that in segments. Those Steely Dan bass lines are awesome, and you play them expertly, with all the feeling, thus the "bass face"!
Definite bass face
This is a perfect riff to learn for when you go to the guitar store and try a bass for the sound tone and quality that you are after
Love The Break, and Then Jim Comes In, So Cool !
What an awesome bass line
So much to digest
Great as always Julia ❤️🎶
I love this bassline, thank you for this lesson!
Welcome back Julia, it’s been a while. You seemed to really enjoy playing that one.
I do :-) // Cheers, Julia
Happy to see your new video.👍
As always Julia CRUSHES her tutorials! Great post and this was super clear. I think that Josie was a really funky fun bass with lots of style (as in 70s bell bottoms and sequins, but I digress). Loved this, and I'm a fan of the Steely Dan popular songs like this. They recorded so clearly and with such excellent tone that its hard not to love their music if you like cool jazzy fusion like sounds. I will use this tutorial to learn how to play it better than I imagined I could previously.
Such a great tune. nicely done Thomann's and to you Julia!
Beautiful.
I was hooked the first time I saw you here and the more I watch the more I like your content. I’ve seen a few videos today and they inspires me to dust off my old bass and try to learn some groovy bass lines. I’m just a happy amateur who used to play in a local rock band with some strong country influences. Nothing fancy really. But I really like the groove from the 70th. You have a sweet style Julia. There is something about the way you express your passion for music.
Awesome again 😊. Thanks Julia.
Hi Julia, I love watching how you enjoy playing the bass. It is contagious. I'm a big Steely Dan/Donald Fagen fan and a beginner bass player. Muchas gracias desde El Paso, TX!
Thank you so much Julia never did I think this bass line was attainable for me as a bassist.Your breakdown and comprehension made it so I was able to unlock it and have sooooo much fun
Thank you very much Julia for your precious explanations. ;-)
What a video, Julia ! Congratulations and many thanks ! See U soon. François
Awesome! This is perfect and it will keep me busy for a while. Please do more detailed breakdowns like this.
Wow, I don't even play bass and watched this entire video. Have been listening to this track since the album was released in '77 and didn't know how sophisticated Mr. Rainey's part was. Sublime!
I often find myself having to learn 30 to 40 new songs for a band I just joined with pending gigs. In this situation, I cut to the chase and look for isolated bass tracks or bass lessons. This video is far and away the best bass lesson I have found on RUclips! The flow and the pace are perfect for me! Thank you Julia Hofer! You will be the first place I check from now on!
Thanks Julia, a well explained lesson !
Thank you so much, Julia!
Julia, you rock 👍
Really like your feel and taste in music. Love the way you get into the groove and stay there..
I'm not a bassist, but I am a big fan of the instrument. You covered this perfectly, including little details so many others might have missed, such as NOT going back to the E on the first time through the figure in the intro, but doing so every other time. Also, your intonation is so clean. Great work!
Julia sei la numero uno!!! Dal tuo viso traspare felicità quando suoni… bravissima!!! 🎶🎶🎶😘
That Bass line was jointly constructed by Chuck Rainey and Walter Becker. Becker was thinking Cop movie incidental music and Chuck embellished it. Great job breaking it down here. The making of AJA is a great Documentary.
Julia, thanks a lot for the lesson. It's inspiring how the groove comes out of you. Please make a lesson for the song San Francisco by Brother Strut. Please
I have seen your work in years and how you cover some of the famous bass lines esp this SD bass....I just had to watch all over again and marvel at how Chuck Rainey was a Bass badass...again thanks for doing this...😅😮😅😮😊
Outstanding Julia!! Thank you.
One of my favorite songs. Brilliant explainer.
Julia doing another Steely Dan video? Best part of MY day.
Worked this bassline more than 30 years ago, and still love it today ! Guitar part too !
Thank you so much sweetie, I have loved this song since It came out (yes I’m old) . Your RUclips movie lesson makes me feel like taking out my bass and learn it. I have enjoyed all of your “Top” bass lines movies but never knew you do how to play it lessons. To groove young lady. I subscribed and did that bell thing long ago but now I’m going to learn how to search. LoL. I wonder if the 30 year old strings on my “P” will still sound good. Hope the tubes in my amp all light up. God Bless sweetheart and keep healthy and yes your playing is inspirational. Most Sincerely, Pops Fitch
I just discovered your channel last night and dayum... After watching this tutorial, it might become one of my favorites! Learning to play the bass guitar has been on my bucket list for decades; and watching this video is inspiring!!
Thanks for posting Julia, I learned this a few years ago and your tutorial is so clear and concise. Greatly appreciated. Chuck Rainey what can you say - he's so groovy.
One of the coolest basslines played by one of the coolest bassplayers. Kudos to you Julia. I have loved playing this bassline and your expressions show you really are channelling Chuck Rainey. I note that it is evident that a bass player wrote this, unlike many songs that it is just a simple backing. He expertly provides a solid foundation but adds the tasty licks, runs and syncopation that makes this outstanding. André in Sydney
Bravo great skill and tuition Julia blessings
I’m not a Bass player, but damn that baseline makes the song! Now, when I listen to Josie, all I focus on is the baseline! Thank you for this!
The thing with Steely Dan is that you can do that with literally every instrument and the vocals. All parts are incredibly groovy, complex, and recorded to perfection.
Steely Dan is always a good time on the bass guitar. Pretty cool Julia.
Another band that is always fun on the bass, is early Chicago. I love comping Peter Cetera's bass lines. He's always been very underrated.
I wouldn't mind having you for my bass teacher, great song
Thank you very much Julia for this lesson. Please more videos like this. For a beginner bassist like me, I can learn this song easier. thanks
Amazing talented lady!
LOVE, LOVE and LOVE…i have to go practice now…
Great song, excellent lesson-thank you so much!
Amazing, I have been trying to learn this song for so long (Correctly) and even though I had the tab and even a lesson (JUST TO LEARN THIS SONG) all i got was some tab and as much as I can cram within an hour lesson and watching the clock.. I never got the feel of it. Thank you Julia!
Love Steely Dan one of my favorites. You do an amazing job.
Damn, that P bass has a really thick sound. I need to check out one of those.
Exquisite!
beautiful
Great lesson/breakdown. Love that quirky little slide chord 😂
The tone of your bass on this vid is stellar!
Great as always Julia....wow......
i love your way julia..thanks a lot!!!!!
You're amazing!
Sehr gut
yess
Great sounding bass, too
Música boa demais 👏👏👏👏👏
Great lesson 🙏❤️🔥
I hope you make more lessons, this is great! Thank You!
Now that bass line is in my head for hours! 😬
Thanks a lot Julia 😉
Thank you for the wonderful explanation and demonstration！
So beautiful！！！
You are wonderful! I'd have to fly from California each week for lessons, but it would be worth it. Love the explanations, slowing it down, and the tablature. Thanks much.
Thanks for this masterpieces bass cover lesson ! Julia is really smart 👍
Thank you very much Julia for this class. I can finally play a song I like a lot like the original, I'm happy. Could you in future videos show us more songs? Bye
i love how you play the bass
This is a great bass line--good job!
Nice
Julia! you're so beautiful and talented! 💐🎸
Great explanation and demo
Felicitaciones, me encantó la clase.
Nice.
My piano coach Victor Feldman played Rhodes on that track.
😺
This is an awesome lesson!
Thank you🙏
Your a great teacher!
I love love love Julia’s bass videos, although she could do a video of her baking a cake and I would watch it !
Very well done!
Julia does such an amazing job of reproducing these parts! I would be highly interested in hearing about her method of figuring these things out.....Please share!
I love your channel. ❤❤❤
Super! TU🙏❣
I don’t play bass or know music theory,, but I enjoyed the heck out of that. Obviously a great bass line, but I love her enthusiasm.
Thank you so much! // Cheers, Julia
Bass lessons covering the entire Aja album? Please and thank you!
Fantastic, you are wonderfull, thanks very much, this realy helped me a lot , quite a difficult song, got to be done right,, you realy helped me ,, exelent😊
Thanks. Your Magic XxX
I'm have been following on my little Acoustic Guiter that's hard work.
Love it so much I'm subscribing now. Thank you. :)
Hi Julia - any chance you can break down a lesson for The Street Beater ... another Chuck Rainey classic?
As always another great video Julia, loving those little fills and variations. I'm sure the song was written for you... 💙👊😎
believe it or not, you got lesson for free... nuts.
This is so cool, thank you Julia! Good to see you, how has your tour been going? ❤